So due to my NBA 2K9 disc crapping out on me, I decided to give in and get NBA Live 09. This is the first NBA Live I’ve played since 2005. I have grown accustomed to the 2K engine and became very fond of it. Plopping in Live 09 and playing it without reading anything besides the button configuration, I got my ass whooped pretty bad. So after reading online, doing some NBA Live Academy drills, I got a better feel for the game. So what do I think?
Defense:
2K9 is better in my opinion. I like 2K9’s in that I can control how tight I want to guard my man and which direction to shade him on the spot. In Live 09, I can “lock-on” to my man by walking up towards him, and have to move my defender along with him. I do like this in that it’s very much a risk-reward system just like playing defense up close on your man in real life. Also, you can lock-on then release, ensentially bodying up your man and disrupting his move, just like in real life! Which is really cool. But I’m not a fan of walking up to my guy to lock-on him. There are times I’m trying to lock-on and I just move past him, so he drives by or shoots, and makes me look like a complete retard. I still like the flexibility 2K9 gives you in-game on how to defend your man. The shading left-right is cool, gives you same risk-reward as Live 09 (though not as much risk) and allows you to guard the man’s side where your big man is not.
Double teaming in 2K9 seems easier to me. I just press the RB (xbox 360 controller) and guy comes over to double. Live 09, I have to hold down B is seems like to get my man to keep coming over. I guess this is good in that you can break off your double team if need be, but it seems to take the 2nd guy ages to come double. And when he does, alot of times he’ll just stand around general area, just chilling.
Rebounding seems to be an issue with me in Live09. I did ok in 2K9, but Live09 just kicks my ass. I guess cuz I’m not used it yet, but seems to me like in Live09 you really have to baby the direction stick when trying to get position in paint and going where you want to to get the rebound. Direction sensitivity seems really high, so I’m just all over the place when I try to grab the board. 2K9 feels more natural to me in this area.
Blocking is about even to me in 2K9 and Live09. But the block animation in Live09 just looks downright funky. The ball just flies straight downard all the time, never any other direction. And the ball always looks like it gets swatted (as in moves really fast) a split second after defender blocks it. Just looks odd.
Passing:
Directional passing in 2K9 works decent. Directional passing in Live09 blows huge donkey nuts.
Icon passing kind’ve a toss-up. In 2K9, you press the button and the icons stay up for a few seconds, you can press it again to make the icons go away before their initally alotted time. In Live09, you have to hold down the button, and icons go away once you let go. I prefer 2K9 on this one, not huge deal though.
Alley-oops look better to me in Live09. In 2K9, animation looks a little awkward in the guy seems to jump really fast and from really far. As far as pulling off alley-oops, both work well to me.
Offense:
I don’t understand why 2K9’s isomotion is viewed as 10x more complex than Live09’s quickstrike. 2K9 you use your left stick to perform crossovers, behind-the-backs, etc… Same with Live09 except you use your right stick. If anything, I have a harder time with Live09 because I can’t seem to explode in a direction after performing my move. Isomotion gets my vote here.
Shot-stick in 2K9 was awesome to me. It did everything from my dunks/lay-ups to my post moves. I could change shot in mid-air, do floaters, up and unders, left/right layups, it was wonderful. Complicated? Yes. But much more flexible. In Live09, they’re still using the seperate shot and dunk buttons. I was actually a fan of this when they first seperated them. But I miss the flexibility of shotstick, and as much as I hear post moves are easy to perform, I’m having a helluva time.
Freethrows in 2K9 seem more authentic, but just impossibly hard. I’m not spending my time memorizing everyone’s freethrow animation. Live09 is too easy, but I can actually make them. I’ll go with Live09 here.
Playcalling in 2K9 works well, you press down on your d-pad to bring up your menu of set plays, which you configure in the coaching menu. I also like having the court diagrammed with the play. Playcalling in Live09 though works awesome. I love being able to call up plays and scroll through pages. I like how the court is diagrammed with where I need to go and who my pass options are, but I’d like to see the actual play diagrammed like in 2K9. Also, for my pass options, they all get an A-button (pass) icon. When I first saw this, I thought pressing A meant it’d pass to my guy set in the play. Instead it passed to nearest guy. Why the hell would I get an A-button icon if I’m not actually passing to those guys? Toss-up for me in this area. I like Live09’s interface alot better, but I like 2K9’s diagramming of plays.
Pick-and-Roll in 2K9 works very well. Depending on how long you press the PnR button (hold or tap), you can fake a screen, have the guy roll, or have guy pop out. Very nice. However, Live09 PnR just kick’s 2K9’s butt. I press PnR button to have guy come over, I can let go before or right when he sets screen to have him roll right away. Or I can wait for the graphic to pop up, have a meter fill up while my man’s setting screen to either roll or pop out. Beautiful. Live09 wins by far here.
Developing players:
You know, I’m reading around that Live09’s Academy is awesome because you run drills that actually train you for the game and that’ll develop your players in dynasty. Wait, then what the fuck has 2K9 been doing all this time? I’ve been doing that since 2K7. Don’t get the big hype here. Toss-up.
Presentation:
2K9 crowds/atmosphere are better. Live09 models are better, though the artistic style of faces I dislike. That’s a personal preference though. Animations are better in 2K9, just looks so much more natural. I think the models make Live09 look more real in pure eye-candy terms, but as far as animation and flow of games, 2K9 has slight edge here.
Having a gym to shootaround at in Live09 is cool. But it’s still to hide the ridiculously long load times. My 2K9 games loaded up fast compared to Live09.
Live365 vs. Living Rosters:
In Live365, if a player is out, he’s on IR. Then when I start a dynasty, all the players in IR disappear from life. So Carlos Boozer is out, I start a dynasty, he ceases to exist. Normally Boozer ceasing to exist is good, but in terms of my enjoyment of dynasty, this fucking sucks far beyond any porno chick is capable of sucking dick. Seriously EA, what the fuck.
Living rosters don’t update as often, but atleast I can play my dynasty in peace.
Misc.:
2K9’s player cards own. I get more info out of that than having to look through Live09’s menus.
Menus in Live09 are fancy, but there’s lag and alot of times my button presses don’t register. Lame.
Live09 has Tony Parker on the cover. Fail.
2K9, you can’t give me some type of indicator at tip-off on when to jump like in Live09? I’ve only won 1 tip-off in the month my 2K9 actually worked. Am I retarded? Probably. But you shouldn’t be rubbing it in my face with your retarded tip-ff. C’mon 2K sports…
Live09, I like how in team chemistry, for each player you list other players and how they like eachother. I don’t know how you calculate this, but it’s something to look at and I like it. Think about this 2K.
Overall I’d have to still take 2K9 if it weren’t for 2K’s cheap-ass discs. The gameplay is more enjoyable to me, and it’s “over-complicated” interface doesn’t bother me as much. And it’s Dynasty rules to me. Live09 does have it’s values. Playcalling and PnR are awesome, it looks good, Live365 really is cool despite it breaking dynasty mode. But the kinks in rebounding and the somewhat awkward defense really turn me off. I probably need more time with Live09 to become more familar. Still, for $10 less, Live09 is good for casual gamers and it will give you a good sim experience with right sliders of course, just not up to 2K9’s sim experience with right sliders in my opinion. Can’t wait for 2010, hopefully Live will come back more refined. Just makes you wish they’d join forces to produce the perfect basketball game. Ah well. Such is life.